A revitalized biopsychosocial model: core theory, research paradigms, and clinical implications PMC

They are useful to the extent that they focus our thinking and action in helpful ways (eg, they contribute to health, well-being, and efficient use of resources), but when taken too literally, they can also entrap and limit us by creating boundaries that need not exist. By maintaining what William James called “fragile” categories,64 we can alter or dispose of categories as new evidence accumulates and when there is a need to engage in flexible, out-of-the-box thinking. For example, although Sober House genetics may have a role in causing schizophrenia, no clinician would ignore the sociologic factors that might unleash or contain the manifestations of the illness. If someone else’s porn addiction is interfering with your quality of life or relationship, you may consider seeking support from trusted friends, family, and trained professionals or support groups. Someone may engage in stress-inducing behavior to relieve stress momentarily, only to experience more negative emotions afterward.

Ch. 1: Introduction to Psychological Models of Addiction

What may be less appreciated among scientists is that its impact in the real world of addiction treatment has remained more limited, with large numbers of patients still not receiving evidence-based treatments. Metacontingencies represent an important approach to addiction because their behavior analytic origins emphasize the role of functional relationships that determine behavior. Unlike other approaches that consider personal factors as imbedded within and inseparable from the social context (e.g., relational autonomy), metacontingencies recognize the separateness yet interdependence of these factors. Bandura argued that social systems are not the products of immaculate conception – they are products of human activity that are designed to influence human development and human functioning (Bandura, 2008). In the collective agency described above, people pool their knowledge, skills and resources to shape their future. Metacontingencies provide an organized structure within which social systems operate and allow collective agency to emerge.

Policy Interventions

In the Tyrili cohort 2016 study, quantitative methods were used to examine quality of life, cognitive functioning, psychological distress and experiences of trauma among 138 patients [5, 40]. The biopsychosocial systems approach provides the impetus for a benevolent view of individuals who have a serious addiction, such as heroin, and the data to date suggest that, however unorthodox, the intervention appropriately address addiction related issues, including stigma, at both the individual and societal level. The social does not necessarily include macrosocial circumstances, such as governmental social policies, drug policy or drug ‘strategy’ that has a direct effect on substance use rates and patterns.

Compulsivity Model

The World Health Organization (WHO) and Norwegian health authority use a comprehensive, multi-disciplinary understanding of SUD based on a biopsychosocial approach. This approach assumes that psychological and biological factors are in constant interplay with relational, social, economic, cultural and political elements in the development and maintenance of SUD and that each person’s pathway to developing SUD is unique [10, 11, 37]. Using substances to cope, feel better, and belong may reduce anxiety, restlessness, disturbing emotions, and feelings of hopelessness and loneliness [14, 19]. The substances affect the brain’s central functions, including dopamine production and executive functions, with a consequent craving for substances and impaired impulse control [47, 49]. This may involve reckless behaviour that is often incomprehensible to other people and may lead to stigma and shame [16, 18, 48]. Mental health problems, such as anxiety and depression, may increase [29], and it may be difficult to maintain social relationships, everyday parenting responsibilities and work routines [18, 34].

  • As we describe above, viewing addictive disorders from an attachment perspective may help promote an improved understanding of these conditions that often carry negative individual and familial impacts.
  • For instance, in many countries, the highest prevalence of substance use problems is found among young adults, aged 18–25 [36], and a majority of these ‘age out’ of excessive substance use [37].
  • In contrast, network-level interventions that target the interactive processes between nodes take advantage of the positive feedback loops inherent to the system to produce effects that are greater than a simple summation of its individual parts.
  • The reciprocal determinism model allows motivational aspects of behavior to be determined by its consequences – a behavior that is positively reinforced is strengthened – reflected by increases in its probability, frequency, rate, and/or intensity in the future.
  • According to this model, the non-eliminable dimensions of addiction are those that relate to the act of using drugs, the personal characteristics of the user, and the contingencies operating in the environment, particularly the social environment.

Indeed, substance use is influenced both by the availability of alternative reinforcers, and the state of the organism. The roots of this insight date back to 1940, when Spragg found that chimpanzees would normally choose a banana over morphine. However, when physically dependent and in a state of withdrawal, their choice preference would reverse [102]. The https://virginiadigest.com/top-5-advantages-of-staying-in-a-sober-living-house/ critical role of alternative reinforcers was elegantly brought into modern neuroscience by Ahmed et al., who showed that rats extensively trained to self-administer cocaine would readily forego the drug if offered a sweet solution as an alternative [103]. This was later also found to be the case for heroin [103], methamphetamine [104] and alcohol [105].

Medication Assisted Treatment

Addiction consists of interacting biological and psychosocial mechanisms because the mechanism (e.g., the behaviour) contributing to addiction involves action within a social system. The larger societal structure either restricts or enhances interactions between agents in a social system (Bunge 1997). The multifaceted disorder needs a multifaceted conceptualization, and we find that in the biopsychosocial model of addiction (Marlatt & Baer, 1988). Rather than pinpoint the one thing that causes addiction, we now understand that a constellation of factors contributes to a person being more or less at risk for addiction. “I believe that [the biopsychosocial model] could enhance their self-awareness and understanding of themselves, along with broadening their personal sense of what issues or challenges may be going on with them,” says Dr. Marsh. Mental health professionals who utilize the biopsychosocial model in practice include extensive medical history, family history, genetics, and social factors in assessments in addition to psychological information.

  • For many people, the process includes stable periods and periods characterised by emotional, relational, and social pain and trouble [6].
  • Think back to the beginning days of the COVID-19 pandemic and how many people were negatively impacted by the social gathering restrictions.
  • Drug use may be transmitted socially by a number of mechanisms (Strickland and Smith, 2014; 2015), and several of these mechanisms have received empirical support.
  • Through observational learning, we learn to imitate both the precise behaviors and general classes of behavior modeled by others in our social environment.
  • A FeaturePaper should be a substantial original Article that involves several techniques or approaches, provides an outlook forfuture research directions and describes possible research applications.

Rather, it may be that the content and emotions that constitute the clinician’s relationship with the patient are the fundamental principles of biopsychosocial-oriented clinical practice, which then inform the manner in which the physician exercises his or her power. The models of relationship that have tended to appear in the medical literature, with a few notable exceptions,19 have perhaps focused too much on an analysis of power and too little on the underlying emotional climate of the clinical relationship. For this reason, we suggest a reformulation of some of the basic principles of the biopsychosocial model according to the emotional tone that engraves the relationship with such characteristics as caring, trustworthiness, and openness.49,50 Some principles of biopsychosocial-oriented clinical practice are outlined below.

Semi-synthetic opiates such as heroin mainly activate mu opioid receptors in the central nervous system (Koob, Sanna, and Bloom 1998). Mu receptors activate analgesia, respiratory depression, miosis, euphoria, and reduced gastrointestinal motility. Frequent and chronic opioid exposure may lead to a significant amount of neuroadaptations, which are believed to contribute to tolerance, withdrawal, and other mechanisms contributing to the cycle of compulsive use and relapse (Christie 2008). Primary features of the model are shown in boldface; variables exemplifying heroin-assisted treatment are shown in italics. This paper builds on the conceptual foundations of Hyman’s (2007) contribution on addiction and voluntary control, and extends the thinking to include perspectives that include, but also go beyond, neuroscience. Giordano, A. L., Prosek, E. A., Stamman, J., Callahan, M. M., Loseu, S., Bevly, C. M., Cross, K., Woehler, E. S., Calzada, R.-M. R., & Chadwell, K.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *